| Trophies | Requirements |
| Bronze | |
| 99 scalps | Make 99 shots in the head. |
| Act i | Complete the first act. |
| Act II | Complete the second act. |
| Act III | Complete the third act. |
| Act IV | Complete the fourth act. |
| Arkansas Fried Rooster | Stop 10 chickens with dynamite. |
| Between there are and grass | The game ends at least in the average difficulty. |
| Boy Scout | A complementary adventure ends. |
| Catchr in the Rye | In chapter 2, in the field, kill enemy soldiers with knives without being detected. |
| Crime Does Pay | Win 5 rounds like an out of the law. |
| Crowbait | The game ends at least in easy difficulty. |
| D-Day | In chapter 1, destroy the rafts before they reach land. |
| Drive-by | Kill 5 enemies about your horse. |
| Fireworks | Shoot 2 dynamite cartridges in the middle of the air. |
| Frang Steal | Kill all enemies in a single mode of cooperative concentration. |
| High Noon | Kill 4 enemies between 12:00 pm and 12.15pm (local time). |
| Jack of All Trade | Play a complete game with each class. |
| Mad Carpenter | Kill 5 enemies with a chair. |
| Man of the Hood | In Chapter 12, playing as Thomas, use only the arc throughout the level. |
| Mayhem | In Chapter 3, he kills 20 armed enemies while driving the diligence. |
| None Shall Hide | Shoot an enemy through a wall. |
| Pistol Expert | Kill 250 people with gun. |
| Quick Hands | Kill 7 people during a concentration mode. |
| Remove Ride | In chapter 9, in the elevator, it destroys what they throw you. |
| Rifle Expert | Kill 250 people using rifles. |
| Rowing-Race Cheater | In Chapter 11, he kills all Indians during the persecution in Canoa. |
| Sharpshoter Destruction | In chapter 4, playing like Thomas, kills the shooters in 10 seconds. |
| Sharpshoter Distraction | In Chapter IV, playing as Ray, kills the shooters without Thomas’ help. |
| Shield of Hope | All complementary adventures end. |
| Shotgun Expert | Kill 250 people with shotguns. |
| Tin Star | Win 5 rounds as a man of the law. |
| Unforgiven | Kill 10 enemies as an invincible search. |
| Vindicator | Kill a total of 30 enemies with the mobile machine gun. |
| WELCOME TO THE FRONTIER | A complete Wild West Legends game ends. |
| Well invest | Buy 20 second level improvements and 10 third level improvements. |
| Yankee Cow | In Chapter 2, don’t kill the cow. |
| Silver | |
| Been There, Done That | Play a complete Wild West Legends game at each level. |
| Curly Wolf | The game ends at the difficult level. |
| Gotta Catch’em All | Collect all secrets. |
| Magnificent Thirteen | Unlock all classes. |
| ON THE RIGHT TRACK | Get a total of 200.000 $ to unlock silver weapons in multiplayer. |
| Ray’s Story | Each chapter plays as Ray. |
| Thomas’ Story | Each chapter plays like Thomas. |
| Untouchable | Each chapter ends, except 6 and 8, without being severely injured. |
| Gold | |
| Forgive Me, Lord | Kill 2.000 enemies. |
| Goldrush! | Get a total of 1.000.000 $ to unlock gold weapons in multiplayer. |
| Old West Legend | The game ends in very difficult mode. |
| Platinum | |
| Ace of Spades | Get all game trophies. |